Tuesday, March 07, 2006

Analyst Day Slide Comments

Putting the powerpoint slides in their raw form on the web was clearly a huge mistake since the company effectively "published" the comments to the world. Ah, the power and danger of the web!

I personally hate Adobe Acrobat as memory hogging bloatware and as the single biggest source of crashes from my otherwise stable system, but this is why the PDF format exists.

Google, how about solving the publishing problem in a better way than Adobe's? There's a clear need and it wouldn't be hard to create a dramatically better solution. GDF anyone?

For those of you interested, here are the slide comments from Eric Schmidt's Analyst Day presentation:

Slide #2 – Globe Slide
So what I thought I could do today is talk about how we think about these very big shifts in media and advertising. And let's just be candid here – there aren't just big shifts in the industry, there are some pretty big problems and challenges facing every significant player in the ecosystem. And the way that we at Google think about these problems is a little different from lots of the other ways that people think about things.
One way to think about it is that Google set itself out to work on problems that involved people – problems that mattered about information at scale – building products and services for the whole world.
I'm a computer scientist. I don't have the media and marketing backgrounds that you all do, so I look at the industry and how it's changing and think this is an opportunity for using technology to solve problems that have never been solved before… or never needed to be solved, until now.

Slide #3 - Big Problems
We have some basic guidelines we use to solve big problems -
We try to identify when our technology can solve an existing problem at worldwide scale.
Google is important to the world and we use that to advantage:
We tackle important problems people really care about
We address large markets with big opportunities
We will make sure everything and everyone has access to Google
Its clear to us that we are just at the beginning of meeting our mission of "Organizing the worlds information and making it universally accessible and useful” We believe that we have less than 5% of the information we should be able to get into our indexes, and we believe that the technologies we will develop will significantly expand the definition of search and the scope and scale of our worldwide business.
For example,
. Video and Print – filling a void in our search products and making sure Google Search has high utility; increasing time users spend with Google; building a competitive advantage in information acquisition and storage; can ultimately lead to niche, extremely targeted/valuable advertising opportunities
. Gmail – reinventing email management; email is where consumers spend an inordinate proportion of overall time online
. Picasa – provide better organization for our digital lives and with the release of online photo management, organize/store more of our important/cherished data with Google
. DesktopSearch – provide high utility and make the access via Google of public and personal information seamless
Think of Google “as ubiquitous as brushing your teeth.”
With 56% of Internet search referrals, Google is the world’s largest search engine.
We are spending 500m+ in CapEx and innovating in products like automatic machine translation in order to make this happen.
We’re taking this learning to advertising and reaching end users………………

Slide #7 -Lead in Search
As the market leader, we need to ensure search doesn’t become a commodity. Our focus on search is nothing new. We built our brand on being the best search engine, with the best results, and as our competitors have caught up to us, it’s become even more important for us to focus on:
1) Speed
Solve international speed issues and bring international users to US performance
2) Comprehensiveness and freshness
“All webpages included in the Google index and searched all the time” – Teragoogle makes this possible
Expand to other sources of data
Become the leader in geo search (any search with a geographic component).
New forms of content – video, audio, offline printed materials
3) Relevance
Leverage implicit and explicit user feedback to improve popular and nav queries
Introduce new personalization elements
4) User Interface
Experiment with several new UI features to make the user experience better

Slide #8 - Drive Search Innovation
To really make good on that last part – improving the user experience, we need to drive search innovation.
For example, we need to provide unified search experience by integrating multiple verticals & data sources through UI and ranking solutions
Add features, not properties and make it really easy to use
Guide users to help them search better
Make query interpretation transparent through UI elements and help users refine queries
Encourage our large user base to actively contribute metadata that leads to better search results
Wiki of search: empower users/experts to improve search results in their domains of expertise — create a million verticals
Effectively integrate user feedback (ratings, comments, tags) into search

Slide #9 - More Complete Ads System
Now let’s look at another core element of our business: advertising. Consider that today, 1 in 4 retail dollars is spent online, and you’ll immediately understand the tremendous opportunity before us.
Our ads business for the moment is healthy and growing and we’re on a strong trajectory
projected to grow from $6bn this year to $9.5bn next year based purely on trends in traffic and monetization growth
But strong competitors are attempting to aggregate traffic
AdSense margins will be squeezed in 2006 and beyond
Y! and MSN will do un-economic things to grow share
The ad network will be commoditized over time
So, we need to build a more complete ads system that is characterized by two words: wider and deeper. That is, cast the net wider to attract new customer types) and deeper to enhance our relationship with existing customers.

Slide #10 – Picture of Cow / "Collective Wisdom"
What does a cow have anything to do with this?
If you haven't read James Surowiecki's "Wisdom of Crowds," I highly recommend it. In the book, Surowiecki tells a story about an experiment done in the 19th century. It was by this British anthropologist named Francis Galton.
What Galton did in the experiment was go to a county fair where he had close to 800 people guess the weight of an ox by writing their guess on a slip of paper. Among the 800 or so people were a lot of ordinary county fair goers but there were also some experts – butchers, cattle farmers, you know, the sort of people who would have a reasonably good idea how much a particular cow should weigh.
The remarkable outcome of this experiment is that when Galton tallied all the guesses, the average guess, that is, the collective guess of the crowd was significantly better than the guess of any individual within the group. Think about that. The crowd was wiser than any individual, and that included the experts.
This principle has proven out over and over. And you see it everywhere: financial markets, political elections, and even the synchronization of traffic.
So let's go back to the Hustle and Flow graph I showed you earlier. But instead of just Hustle and Flow, think about every single piece of content ever created and owned by CBS. Now let me ask you a few questions – these are rhetorical:
* Do you know exactly how many assets you have? By assets, I mean all the content you've ever owned or created. Do you know exactly? Do you have the count? (Remember, I'm a computer scientist. I have to ask these things.)
* What percentage of your assets is currently available to users such that they can access it any time, view it, enjoy it any time? And I don't necessarily mean on Google Video, but it could be on your own web sites. What percentage? Pretty small?
* Now let's say you could suddenly make all your assets available to users worldwide. If this happened, do you know which of your assets would be most popular? Would it be last season's Survivor finale? Or would it be a segment from 60 Minutes that might have aired 10 years ago? Do you know which assets would be most popular in Miami vs. most popular in Ft. Lauderdale? Or in the U.S. vs. in Cambodia? Or on Wednesday mornings vs. Sunday nights?
Here's a fact that I've learned while at Google and I want to share it with you: a company is not smarter than the consumers of that company's products.

Slide #11 - More Complete Ads System (continued)
By Wider, we mean:
Simplifying the experience and streamline advertiser acquisition for small and medium-sized businesses
Developing a great branding product for large online advertisers and for offline advertisers of all sizes
Expanding offerings to include print, radio, TV, and direct mails
By Deeper, we mean:
Providing Advanced Tools & Reporting for sophisticated advertisers (e.g., API, bid management, ad scheduling)
Expanding AdWords from clicks to conversions (e.g., Landing Page Optimization, Google Analytics integration)
Tightening integration with other Google products (e.g., SiteMaps, GoogleBase, Local)
To really get down to brass tacks, we’re going to:
Execute well on our core ads projects to help us exceed the $9.5bn target (and backfill any AdSense partner loss) and drive advertiser satisfaction
Quality initiatives (e.g. landing page quality)
Fight hard to maintain share in the AdSense network
Aggressive guarantees
Increased monetization on existing pages
Expand inventory rapidly through:
Support for new ad formats
Targeting other types of media
Developing market-leading/”hit” Google properties and consumer applications
Extend into adjacent SMB services (CBG is only a first step)
Treat advertisers as full-fledged businesses with a broad set of needs (not just advertising)
Ensure that we are not supplanted in the consumer buying cycle by eBay, AMZN, Yahoo in their effort to become one-stop shops in the full buying cycle
By bringing more product information to Google (e.g. via Base)
By providing users with a richer search experience (e.g. attribute search, vertical search, and richer product information and reviews)
By leveraging CCC apps to provide users with the product/service information they care about when they want it

Slide #13 - Solve Big Problems
In the US alone, there is $250B spent in advertising. Is there a problem here? I’m guessing that the title of the day today has something to do with it – can you make $250B more accountable?
Accountability in marketing, having run another F1000 company, generally came from my Mom. I would spend $100M on TV ads and the only accountability I had was my Mom calling to say she liked the fish we used in our ads.
The U.S. Advertising Marketing (2005E)
Internet is $11.3B, and of that Search advertising was $3.84B 2004 and projected to be $4.7 B 2005E
Source: Universal McCann, 12/05
Of this roughly $4B total search revenue; Google has 79% share, which is 27% of the total U.S. Internet advertising, or 1% of all U.S. advertising
Source: eMarketer February 2005, eMarketer May 2005; Note: U.S. Search – comparative estimates from 5 sources; U.S. Online – comparative estimates from 12 sources
Given current growth rates, online advertising will approximate the size of
cable TV today, in 2007; and online advertising will be the size of
radio advertising today, in 2009
Internet growth is the most aggressive, with cable the second most aggressive; other media are trying to keep single digit positive growth
Additional soundbites:
How long it took to reach 50M users of various media
Radio took 37 years to get to 50M listeners
TV took 15 years to get to 50M viewers
Cable took 6 years to get to 50M viewers
Internet took just 3 years to get to 50M users
And how long it took to reach $1B in advertising spending on various media
Radio took 45 years to get to $1B in ad spending
TV took 10 years to get to $1B in ad spending
Cable TV took 7 years to get to $1B in ad spending
Internet took just 3 years to get to $1B in ad spending
Source: Morgan Stanley Technology Research
"Other" includes outdoor, product placement, satellite radio, movie trailers, video games, specialty marketing

Slide #14 - Consumer Products and Services
In a world with infinite storage, bandwidth, and CPU power, here's what we could do with consumer products…
Theme 1: Speed
Seems simple, but should not be overlooked because impact is huge. Users don't realize how slow things are until they get something faster.
Users assume it takes time for a webpage to load, but the experience should really be instantaneous.
Gmail started to do this for webmail, but that's just a small first step. Infinite bandwidth will make this a reality for all applications.
Theme 2: Store 100% of User Data
With infinite storage, we can house all user files, including: emails, web history, pictures, bookmarks, etc and make it accessible from anywhere (any device, any platform, etc).
We already have efforts in this direction in terms of GDrive, GDS, Lighthouse, but all of them face bandwidth and storage constraints today. For example: Firefox team is working on server side stored state but they want to store only URLs rather than complete web pages for storage reasons. This theme will help us make the client less important (thin client, thick server model) which suits our strength vis-a-vis Microsoft and is also of great value to the user.
As we move toward the "Store 100%" reality, the online copy of your data will become your Golden Copy and your local-machine copy serves more like a cache. An important implication of this theme is that we can make your online copy more secure than it would be on your own machine.
Another important implication of this theme is that storing 100% of a user's data makes each piece of data more valuable because it can be access across applications. For example: a user's Orkut profile has more value when it's accessible from Gmail (as addressbook), Lighthouse (as access list), etc.
Theme 3: Transparent Personalization
The more data, access, and processing Google can handle for the user, the greater our ability to use that data to transparently optimize the user's experience.
Google Desktop w/ RSS Feeds is a good first example: the user should not have to tell us which RSS feeds they want to subscribe to. We should be able to determine this implicitly.
Other potential examples: User should not have to specify the "From" address in Google Maps; user should not have to specify which currency they want to see Froogle prices in; user should not have to manually enter their buddy list into Google Talk.

Slide #15 - Google Evolution
How we plan to use our past experience and advantages to help advertising………
Google’s strategy is built upon the same foundation as all of our products and services:
1) Lowest cost, highest performance hardware infrastructure
New computing designs, communications and data center infrastructure
100x better than industry network size
2) Worlds best memory-based software architecture
Making programming easy and reliable on this new model
Making execution as reliable as storage is today
Making large scale computation made very easy
Automatic and market-based machine allocation with real economics
This foundation and framework will enable Google to set new standards for innovation and comprehensiveness. We plan to:
Get all the worlds information, not just some
Crawl everything online (crawl and feeds)
Use our distribution to get their information and also get it structured; make it easy to give to us
Offer good tools for web masters to help understand their inclusiveness
Expand to include other, new information: Video, Print, Photos.

Slide #16 -
More details on mobile devices and the global market
In this context, mobile devices play a key role.
When you look at really important developing markets like India, China, Latin America, mobile phone penetration by far outpaces PCs and laptops. In these regions especially, we need to build products for the next billion users and build stronger relationships with mobile service providers to make sure people have access to them.
Consider this: 1 in 6 people in the world live in India
1/3 of the world's population is in China + India
4B people in the world have never made a phone call
This points to an extremely compelling need to localize our products and make them available and relevant to people who speak languages other than English, and who don’t have ready access to PCs.
Furthermore, 79% of Internet users are outside the US and 67% of them primarily speak a language other than English – the bottom line is we’d be doing our users and our company a disservice to not focus on making our products relevant and compelling to a non-American, non-English-speaking audience.

Slide #18 -
The Seven Themes
I’ll cover each of these areas in greater detail in this presentation, but our strategy can be divided into seven main themes that cover our entire business:
1) Lead in Search: Deliver on Search fundamentals, and innovate new Search models
2) Provide a more complete Ads system: Wider and deeper (best user experience and best ROI)
3) Solve users’ needs and desires beyond Search: Create, Remember, & Share
4) Build the best hardware & software infrastructure: Leverage our lead in hw and sw to our increased advantage
5) Build the biggest footprint: extend Google services to users wherever they are
6) Scale to our huge opportunity: hire the best, leverage bottom-up innovation, grow with core values intact
7) Establish thought leadership position in industry and beyond: work with extended partners, regulators, media and centers of influence


Blogger Karan said...

Hi Derrick,

Do you have all the slide comments? I noticed you posted slide 19 comments on Greg LInden's site but not in your post.


3:06 PM  
Blogger Greg Linden said...

Derrick, do you have a copy of the original PPT file? Are you willing to make it available?

4:39 PM  
Blogger alwayslookaround said...

why not just host and post a link to the entire PPT?

9:15 PM  
Blogger Jean-Marie Le Ray said...

Wooow! What a post! Absolutely brilliant.
I'd like to translate it but I've got no time now.
Really an Absolute Value post.
Keep on going,

9:09 AM  
Blogger Derrick said...

Original powerpoint posted here.

11:58 AM  
Blogger Jean-Marie Le Ray said...

Hi Derrick,

About the PPT file at tomcaster.com, I downloaded it but notes are not available anymore.
Anyway, with this post and the Greg one, I think all notes are known now.

12:16 PM  
Blogger Jean-Marie Le Ray said...

Hi Derrick,

I tried to restore the presentation by binding each slide with its respective comment. You'll find it on my blog, I left everything in English after the first paragraphs, but I'll try to get the Google authorization to translate it. Just a dream...
Jean-Marie Le Ray

3:48 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home